Operated by FINANCE TRANSPARENCY CIC, a non-profit community interest company.

Most retail traders lose money

Thinking of trading? Do the maths first

Trading apps make buying and selling effortless; making money is another matter. Size positions, count the costs and test whether a strategy has any edge before risking real money.

Coverage: United Kingdom first, with notes for the United States where rules differ. Last reviewed 2026-11-22. General information only — not financial, legal or medical advice.

Position size calculator

Professionals decide how much they can lose before they decide how much to buy. Set your risk per trade and your stop level.

Runs in your browser. Nothing you enter is sent or stored.

Stops are not guaranteed: prices can gap through them. Costs are not included.

Trading cost calculator

Small fees add up. Estimate the yearly cost of trading on an app, including currency conversion on overseas shares.

Runs in your browser. Nothing you enter is sent or stored.

Platform, subscription and fund fees are extra. 'Commission-free' does not mean cost-free.

Do you have an edge? Break-even calculator

A strategy only makes money if wins outweigh losses after costs. Enter figures from your own trading record.

Runs in your browser. Nothing you enter is sent or stored.

Illustrative. A small sample of trades says little: a run of luck can look like skill for months.

Capital Gains Tax on shares, 2026/27

For shares held outside an ISA or pension. Gains inside an ISA or pension are tax-free.

Runs in your browser. Nothing you enter is sent or stored.

Sources: GOV.UK: Capital Gains Tax rates and allowances

Simplified: a basic-rate taxpayer pays 24% on any part of the gain that pushes them into the higher-rate band. Spread betting profits are not normally subject to Capital Gains Tax; CFD profits are.

The arithmetic of losses

Losses and gains are not symmetrical. The deeper the hole, the steeper the climb back.

If you loseYou need to gainTo get back to where you started
10%11%Manageable
20%25%Hard
33%50%Very hard
50%100%You must double your money
75%300%Rarely achieved
90%900%Effectively gone

What are you actually trading?

ProductLeverageCan you lose more than you put in?UK tax (in brief)
Shares and ETFsNone unless you borrowNoCapital Gains Tax; 0.5% stamp duty on most UK share purchases
Spread betsYes, up to regulatory limitsNo, with a UK-regulated firm (retail clients)Generally free of Capital Gains Tax for individuals
CFDsYes, up to regulatory limitsNo, with a UK-regulated firm (retail clients)Capital Gains Tax
OptionsBuilt inBuyers: no. Sellers: yes, potentially without limitCapital Gains Tax
CryptoVaries; often offshoreDepends on the platformCapital Gains Tax on disposals

Sources: FCA: contracts for difference · GOV.UK: tax when you buy shares

Tax treatment depends on your circumstances and can change. Frequent trading can, in rare cases, be treated as a trade for Income Tax.

The big market indices, decoded

IndexWhat it tracksWorth knowing
FTSE 100The 100 largest companies listed in London by market valueMost of their revenue is earned outside the UK
FTSE 250The next 250 London-listed companiesMore closely tied to the UK economy
S&P 500500 large US companiesThe usual benchmark for US shares; dominated by a few technology giants
Dow Jones Industrial Average30 large US companiesWeighted by share price, not company size
Nasdaq-100100 large non-financial companies on the Nasdaq exchangeHeavily weighted to technology
DAX40 large German companiesIncludes reinvested dividends, unlike most headline indices
Nikkei 225225 large Japanese companiesPrice-weighted, like the Dow
MSCI WorldLarge and mid-sized companies in 23 developed marketsAbout 70% US by value, despite the name

You cannot buy an index directly. Index funds and ETFs track them for a small fee; CFDs and spread bets on indices are leveraged bets, not investments.

'Finfluencers', signals and copy trading: the warning signs

Sources: FCA: finfluencers · FCA Warning List

Before you place a trade

Trading glossary

Leverage
Borrowed exposure: a small deposit controls a larger position.
Drawdown
The fall from an account's peak to its lowest point.
Spread
The difference between the buy and sell price.
Liquidity
How easily an asset can be bought or sold without moving the price.
Day trading
Opening and closing positions within the same day.
Short selling
Betting on a price fall.
Gamification
App features such as confetti, streaks and leaderboards that encourage more frequent trading.

Retail Trading Risks: questions and answers

16 questions

How it works

Should I trust trading tips from social media 'finfluencers'?

UKBe cautious: promoting financial products without authorisation is illegal in the UK, and influencers may be paid to promote products without saying so.

Check whether the person or firm is authorised, and look for clear risk warnings. Never act on pressure to buy quickly.

Official sources: FCA – finfluencers · FCA ScamSmart

What is leveraged or margin trading?

UKUSTrading with borrowed money or leveraged products, which magnifies both gains and losses and can lose you more quickly than your original stake.

Understand margin calls and how positions can be closed automatically. Our sister site forex.ngo covers CFDs and forex in detail.

Official sources: FCA – contracts for difference · SEC – Investor.gov

How do trading apps make money?

UKUSFrom trading fees and spreads, currency conversion fees, subscriptions, interest kept on uninvested cash and, in some cases, lending out shares.

'Commission-free' does not mean free. Check the FX fee on overseas shares and the rate paid on cash. In the UK, the FCA considers receiving payment for order flow incompatible with brokers' duties, but it is permitted in the US.

Official sources: SEC – Investor.gov · FCA Financial Services Register

Are trading apps a good idea for beginners?

UKUSThey can be a cheap way to invest, but features that make frequent trading easy, such as notifications, leaderboards and leveraged products, can encourage risky behaviour.

Decide your plan before you open the app: long-term investing in diversified funds is very different from active trading. Avoid CFDs and options unless you fully understand them.

Official sources: FCA ScamSmart · SEC – Investor.gov

What happens to my investments if I delete the app or the company closes?

UKDeleting the app does not close your account; if the firm fails, UK rules require client money and assets to be held separately so they can be returned, and the FSCS may cover shortfalls up to its limit.

Investments held on a regulated platform are usually held in a nominee account in your name. If the firm is unregulated, these protections may not apply. Close accounts formally and download statements.

Official sources: Financial Services Compensation Scheme · FCA Financial Services Register

Is it risky to use more than one trading app?

UKUsing several regulated apps is fine, and can spread the risk of any single firm failing, but it can make it harder to track costs, tax and how much risk you are taking overall.

FSCS protection applies per person per firm. Keep records of all trades for tax, and remember the annual ISA allowance applies across all your ISAs.

Official sources: Financial Services Compensation Scheme · GOV.UK – Individual Savings Accounts

What should I look for in a trading app?

UKUSWe do not recommend apps, but check that the firm is regulated, compare all costs including FX fees, see what investments and account types (such as ISAs) it offers, and avoid leveraged products as a beginner.

Read the key information documents and check how to withdraw. Look at complaints data and what protection applies to your money.

Official sources: FCA Financial Services Register · SEC – Investor.gov

Why has my trading account not been approved for some investments?

UKUSBrokers must check whether complex products such as options, CFDs or margin trading are appropriate for you, and can refuse access if your answers show limited experience or knowledge.

This is a protection, not an error. Do not change your answers just to get access. In the US, options trading requires separate approval levels.

Official sources: FCA Financial Services Register · SEC – Investor.gov

Are 'halal' or Shariah-compliant trading accounts what they claim?

UKSome firms offer accounts they describe as Shariah-compliant, such as 'swap-free' forex accounts, but the label is not regulated, so ask who certified it and what fees replace the interest charges.

A religious label does not reduce investment risk or replace regulatory checks. The firm must still be authorised. Swap-free accounts may charge administration fees instead of overnight interest.

Official sources: FCA Financial Services Register · FCA ScamSmart

How do trading apps hold my shares?

UKUSMost apps hold your shares in a nominee account: the shares are registered in the nominee's name but held for you and kept separate from the firm's own money.

Fractional shares are often held by the platform on your behalf, and voting rights may be limited. Read the terms to see how corporate actions and dividends are handled.

Official sources: FCA Financial Services Register · SEC – Investor.gov

Costs, tax and value

What does it really cost to trade?

UKUSCosts can include commission, the spread between buying and selling prices, currency conversion fees, account fees and, for leveraged products, overnight financing.

'Commission-free' does not mean free: check the currency fee and spread. Frequent trading multiplies costs.

Official sources: MoneyHelper · SEC – Investor.gov

Do I pay tax on trading gains?

UKUsually, yes: in the UK, gains above your annual allowance may be subject to Capital Gains Tax, unless the investments are held in a tax wrapper such as a stocks and shares ISA.

Allowances and rates change; check current figures on GOV.UK. Spread betting may be treated differently.

Official sources: GOV.UK – Capital Gains Tax · GOV.UK – Individual Savings Accounts

Staying safe

How do I check a trading app or broker?

UKUSCheck the firm on the FCA register in the UK, or with FINRA BrokerCheck and the SEC in the US, and use the contact details shown there.

Check the warning lists for clone firms that copy real brokers.

Official sources: FCA Financial Services Register · FINRA BrokerCheck

Are AI trading apps legitimate?

UKUSBe very cautious: apps and platforms promising high returns from 'AI' or 'quantum' trading, often promoted with fake celebrity endorsements, are a common investment scam.

Warning signs include guaranteed returns, pressure to deposit more, a personal 'account manager' and problems withdrawing. Check the firm on the FCA register and the warning list.

Official sources: FCA ScamSmart · FTC – investment scams

How can I tell whether a trading app is real?

UKUSCheck that the company behind the app is authorised by the FCA, or registered with the SEC and FINRA in the US, and that the app is published under that company's name.

Fake apps can appear in app stores, and scammers met through dating or social media often direct people to them. If you are told to download a specific app to invest, check the firm independently first.

Official sources: FCA Financial Services Register · FINRA BrokerCheck

If things go wrong

What protection do I have if my trading platform fails?

UKUSIf an FCA-authorised firm fails and cannot return your money or investments, the FSCS may compensate you up to its limit; it never covers losses from falling prices.

In the United States, SIPC protects customers of failed member brokers within limits, but not against market losses.

Official sources: Financial Services Compensation Scheme · SIPC (US)

Official help and where to check

The list above contains public bodies and non-profit services only. Any company named elsewhere on this site is mentioned for information only; we have no commercial relationship with any organisation named.

About this site

trading.ngo is a public-interest website of FINANCE TRANSPARENCY CIC, a non-profit community interest company registered in England and Wales (company number 17530096). It belongs to our Programme 1 · Money & Investor Protection. We sell nothing, carry no advertising and take no commission. The company is asset-locked, and its websites and domain names are used only for its community purpose and are not for sale.

About us, our principles and governance · Every source cited on this site · Corrections and right of reply: contact@trading.ngo